Servers stuck at grub rescue (attempt to read or write outside of disk hd0)

[mmitech]

Half of my servers are stuck at grub rescue after the latest update (pve-manager/7.2-11/b76d3178 kernel 5.15.60-1-pve) and I am afraid to even restart the other servers.
I spent all day yesterday and today trying to fix the grub issues to no avail, I tried this https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/Recover_From_Grub_Failure and a bunch of similar grub-install/grub update methods which none worked.
this is what I get "error: attempt to read or write outside of disk hd0"

 

[mmitech]

I am hoping that there is a way to fix this without having to reinstall proxmox, I have multiple VMs on these servers that would take forever to recover

 

[mmitech]

multiple grub installs, config changes..etc with no help.

I don't want to reinstall the OS, I have a lot of data that I'd need to migrate on at least 3 servers, so I would rather fix this issue instead.

 

[fabian]

this is usually the result of
- big disks or hardware raid (the latter might just "lie" about the disk size)
- in combination with legacy bios

grub gets the disk size from bios/HW raid firmware and honors that, even if the reported size might be lower than the actual disk size. if any of the files it needs to read (grub modules/.., kernel, initrd) are outside of this boundary you will get this error.

there are a few solutions/workarounds:
- switch to UEFI which handles modern disk sizes (but might not help if you are using HW raid)
- move /boot to another disk/partition that is small enough to not bother grub
- rewrite the affected files (workaround, requires "luck" so they end up in the front part of the disk)

 

[mmitech]

Indeed I am using a hardware Raid10 (16 x 900GB SAS disks with a Dell PERC H710 controller), this configuration has been working for a year without any issue, until the last update, 3 of the 5 servers I restarted were stuck at grub rescue.

- move /boot to another disk/partition that is small enough to not bother grub
- rewrite the affected files (workaround, requires "luck" so they end up in the front part of the disk)

I would be interested in those 2 solutions, however, I tried to move grub on a USB drive, I created 2 partitions ( EF02 from sector 34 to 2047 and the other EF00 from sector 2048 to sector 1050623) then I booted with live cd mounted the old disk and did grub-install --boot-directory=/mnt /dev/sdb (sdb being the USB)

when I try to boot I get the same error but now hd1 instead of hd0, am I missing something, is there a guide I should follow for that?

what about rewriting files? which files do I need to rewrite?

 

[fabian]

Indeed I am using a hardware Raid10 (16 x 900GB SAS disks with a Dell PERC H710 controller), this configuration has been working for a year without any issue, until the last update, 3 of the 5 servers I restarted were stuck at grub rescue.

yeah, then likely the raid controller tells Grub something like "the disk is 4TB", while the virtual disk it exposes is bigger. the issue has always been there, you just avoided to trigger it so far.

I would be interested in those 2 solutions, however, I tried to move grub on a USB drive, I created 2 partitions ( EF02 from sector 34 to 2047 and the other EF00 from sector 2048 to sector 1050623) then I booted with live cd mounted the old disk and did grub-install --boot-directory=/mnt /dev/sdb (sdb being the USB)

when I try to boot I get the same error but now hd1 instead of hd0, am I missing something, is there a guide I should follow for that?

grub-install will only install the bootloader to that device, you also need to move /boot to that and then re-run grub-install and update-grub.

what about rewriting files? which files do I need to rewrite?

helpfully, grub doesn't tell you what it tries to read like I said, it can be any of the grub files in /boot, or the kernel, or the initrd.

 

[mmitech]

grub-install will only install the bootloader to that device, you also need to move /boot to that and then re-run grub-install and update-grub.

OK, any idea how would I do that? Are there any docs out there I could read on/follow? I am trying to save these servers without having to reinstall (avoiding that at all costs )

 

[fabian]

the steps are similar to what's described here: https://aaronlauterer.com/blog/2021/move-grub-and-boot-to-other-disk/ but you will have to adapt some details (disk paths, LVM activation since your / is likely on LVM, ...)

 

[mmitech]

the steps are similar to what's described here: https://aaronlauterer.com/blog/2021/move-grub-and-boot-to-other-disk/ but you will have to adapt some details (disk paths, LVM activation since your / is likely on LVM, ...)

OK, I will try this and report! Thanks for the help for now!

 

[mmitech]

@fabian Thanks for your help, copying all boot files and installing grub on a USB drive resolved the issue!

 

[alexvyi]

this is usually the result of
- big disks or hardware raid (the latter might just "lie" about the disk size)
- in combination with legacy bios

grub gets the disk size from bios/HW raid firmware and honors that, even if the reported size might be lower than the actual disk size. if any of the files it needs to read (grub modules/.., kernel, initrd) are outside of this boundary you will get this error.

there are a few solutions/workarounds:
- switch to UEFI which handles modern disk sizes (but might not help if you are using HW raid)
- move /boot to another disk/partition that is small enough to not bother grub
- rewrite the affected files (workaround, requires "luck" so they end up in the front part of the disk)

I can confirm that switching to UEFI works WITH HW Raid.

 

[fabian]

I can confirm that switching to UEFI works WITH HW Raid.

yeah, it depends on the exact hardware and firmware involved, that's why I qualified it like that

 

[petru]

your help, copying all boot files and installing grub on a USB

yeah, it depends on the exact hardware and firmware involved, that's why I qualified it like that

I had the same issue. Switching from BIOS to UEFI helped me to correct the issue. Thank you for your help, guys!

 

[greybeard74]

ProxMox 8.2.2 still has this issue on a Dell Poweredge R710 with hardware RAID on a PERC 700 card. After installing the Linux OS, I just switched the BIOS settings to UEFI and the Linux OS booted.

 

[zvangi]

Just updated my PBS and im getting this issue. I can choose 6.5.11-6 from advenced settings and it boots but anything else is not booting.



Edit:

Changing BIOS to OVMF (UEFI) fixed the issue but I still have to choose the kernel version on reboots

 

[fabian]

you need to do what it says there - add an EFI disk to store EFI variables (and maybe, re-install your boot loader/..)