Unable to create SDN VNet without tag

[nharrington]

I'm having an issue transitioning to the Proxmox VE Software-Defined Network (SDN).

Current situation:
enp6s0f0 is an untagged network connection
vmbr100 is a Linux bridge with bridge port = enp6s0f0
VM998 has a network device attached to vmbr100
This configuration works great

When I try to create a Zone in SDN:
If I choose Simple, there is no option to assign a bridge as it is for creating isolated networks
If I choose VLAN, I am able to create the zone and assign it to vmbr100

When I try to create a VNet:
I enter a Name, Alias, and assign it to the VLAN zone I created above, but when I click Create I receive an error:
create sdn vnet object failed: 400 Parameter verification failed. tag: missing vlan tag (500)

As the underlying network connection doesn't use VLAN tagging, what should I enter in the Tag field?

 

[nharrington]

As a follow-up, it is my understanding that...

Normal VLAN IDs range from 1-4094

A VLAN ID of 0 is reserved and indicates that the frame does not carry a VLAN ID. That seems applicable in my scenario, but it resulted in an error message:
The minimum value for this field is 1

A VLAN ID of 4095 is reserved for implementation use and must not be configured or transmitted.
I received an error message when using a VLAN ID of 9999:
create sdn vnet object failed: 400 Parameter verification failed. tag: vlan tag max value is 4096 (500)
It seems like this upper limit check should be reduced to 4094.

 

[arogarth]

Hey, workaround to get a untagged SDN VLAN:

* Create a SDN VLAN with any tag (eg. 1)
* Deploy it
* ssh to the node and edit /etc/pve/sdn/vnets.cfg, locate your vlan and edit the tag to 0
* Deploy it on the UI

 

[nharrington]

Hey, workaround to get a untagged SDN VLAN:

* Create a SDN VLAN with any tag (eg. 1)
* Deploy it
* ssh to the node and edit /etc/pve/sdn/vnets.cfg, locate your vlan and edit the tag to 0
* Deploy it on the UI

Thanks for the suggestion! I gave this a try but couldn't get it to work. I created new SDN VLAN 1, deployed, edited vnets.cfg, changed tag to 0, then deployed again with the following error:

netlink : error: netlink: vmbr101: cannot add bridge vlan 0: Invalid VLAN start 0

TASK ERROR: command 'ifreload -a' failed: exit code 1

Have you been able to get this to work using this method?

 

[sw-omit]

The way I've done it in our setup was to use SDN's for all the VLAN's and just use the vmbr-bridge itself for any untagged traffic.

Untagged network, where all the hardware resides, is only used in very special cases for us, like 1 in 100 VM's roughly, so only the sysadmins have permission to assign to the bridges and as such untagged network. Al the (normal) Admins only have access to the pre-tagged and labelled SDN-networks.

Less chance of mess if a mistake is made, and the one time they do need a VM with untagged access, it goes through one of us for verification and assignment, plus our company is small enough that those kind of requests are as quick as walking a desk or two over.

 

[nharrington]

The way I've done it in our setup was to use SDN's for all the VLAN's and just use the vmbr-bridge itself for any untagged traffic.

Untagged network, where all the hardware resides, is only used in very special cases for us, like 1 in 100 VM's roughly, so only the sysadmins have permission to assign to the bridges and as such untagged network. Al the (normal) Admins only have access to the pre-tagged and labelled SDN-networks.

Less chance of mess if a mistake is made, and the one time they do need a VM with untagged access, it goes through one of us for verification and assignment, plus our company is small enough that those kind of requests are as quick as walking a desk or two over.

Thanks! That's what I'm currently doing. I was just hoping I could manage everything via SDN. It may even be that SDN would simply pass it through to the underlying vmbr-bridge, but at present it doesn't appear that it's possible to do that.

 

[arogarth]

@nharrington I re-test it and it worked for me. Which PVE Version are aou running? We currently run 8.2.4.
The underlying bridge is a untagged OVS-Bridge.

​

Example config

zones.conf

vlan: testzone
    bridge vmbr1
    ipam pve

vnets.conf

vnet: test
    zone testzone
    alias test
    tag 0

interfaces

auto vmbr1
iface vmbr1 inet manual
    ovs_type OVSBridge
    ovs_ports eno1

 

[nharrington]

@nharrington I re-test it and it worked for me. Which PVE Version are aou running? We currently run 8.2.4.
The underlying bridge is a untagged OVS-Bridge.

8.2.4 here as well, however I'm not running OVS so that's probably a factor. I'll look into that when I get some free time. Thanks for the info!

 

[katamadone]

had the same problem with SDN.
I do have VM wich are using the "same untagged" net as the host himself.