Newbie questions: retention, datastore,

masgo

Well-Known Member
Jun 24, 2019
68
15
48
74
I have been using PVE for some years and I want to also use PBS now. It seems like I don't quite get some of the concepts.
My setup is: one PVE cluster and one PBS on a separate physical machine.
The PBS has 1 SSD as boot drive (with zfs) and a raid-z2 array of 6 HDDs for storage (called localHDD)

Questions
Networking

Each node of my PVE cluster has 2 Gigabit NICs which connect to separate switches (Link 0 with IPs 10.x.x.x and Link 1 with IPs 192.168.x.x). Link 0 is used for corosync, Link 1 for VM traffic and everything else.
My PBS has two Gigabit NICs as well. How should I configure it? Use only one NIC and connect it ot Link 1? .. Use both NICs in an LACP bond to the Link 1 switch (this would allow for parallel backups from different PVE nodes). .. Other ideas?

Datastores
I want to use the raid-z2 array to store PBS backups and samba shares for application-level backups. I also want to have storage quotas for each of them.
If I understood the access control, I can only give a user datastore access. So in order to separate datastore access of different teams, i need different datastores?
Should I create zfs sub-filesystems (localHDD/pbs-teamA, localHDD/pbs-teamB, localHDD/samba, ...etc.) and add them as datastores to PBS? Is this a good idea? / A normal way to do it?

Retention / pruning
It looks like, I can configure retention policies in the PVE backups. In that case the user needs to have prune rights on the datastore. This is a security problem if the PVE cluster should be hacked/infected, because the hacker could delete the backups, right?
So I should only handout the Datastore.Backup right, and not Modify and Prune, correct?
Then I need to configure retention policies in the PBS interface. But how do I define different policies for different VMs?

What are namespaces?

Dedpuplication / Incremental backups
I have read that PBS does use deduplication and incremental backups. Can I configure this somehow? How is it done? zfs-dedup? The documentation is very brief here.

Remote Sync
I want to store the Backups in two different locations. Do I need another PBS or is a simple NAS good enough?
 
Each node of my PVE cluster has 2 Gigabit NICs which connect to separate switches (Link 0 with IPs 10.x.x.x and Link 1 with IPs 192.168.x.x). Link 0 is used for corosync, Link 1 for VM traffic and everything else.
its better to have separat Nics or Vlans for Client, Management and Backup Network. So, u should buy more network cards.
Should I create zfs sub-filesystems (localHDD/pbs-teamA, localHDD/pbs-teamB, localHDD/samba, ...etc.) and add them as datastores to PBS? Is this a good idea? / A normal way to do it?
For samba it is a good idea to create a subvol, but different datastore do not need this. A datastore is a Folder in the Volume.
Then I need to configure retention policies in the PBS interface. But how do I define different policies for different VMs?
retention is always according to a datastore not to the objects of a datastore.
What are namespaces?
yes, there are no explaination. namespaces are like groups, so you can store VMs with the same name/ID from different clusters
Can I configure this somehow? How is it done? zfs-dedup?
no. it's always built-in dedup and compression and incremental. no use of zfs features.
I want to store the Backups in two different locations. Do I need another PBS or is a simple NAS good enough?
Normally u use a second or third PBS as remote server for syncing. Of course, U can use a remote zfs server to send a zfs vol.
 

About

The Proxmox community has been around for many years and offers help and support for Proxmox VE, Proxmox Backup Server, and Proxmox Mail Gateway.
We think our community is one of the best thanks to people like you!

Get your subscription!

The Proxmox team works very hard to make sure you are running the best software and getting stable updates and security enhancements, as well as quick enterprise support. Tens of thousands of happy customers have a Proxmox subscription. Get yours easily in our online shop.

Buy now!