dkim

[Amgems]

Trying to get DKIM sorted. I believe I have the TXT record correct, per https://mxtoolbox.com/.
I have pmg set to sign all outgoing email.
I am trying to verify, using: https://www.dmarctester.com/, and echo hi | mail -s test xxxx@dmarctester.com where the email addr is provided on the WEB site.

Neo claims I am not sigining the email I send.

pmg.admin.dkim-use-domain = header
pmg.admin.dkim_selector = pmg
pmg.admin.dkim_sign = 1
pmg.admin.dkim_sign_all_mail = 1

I've tried envelope as well as header. Neither result in DKIM signed emails.

neo.dmarctester.com
>> Running DKIM
-------------------
I see you haven't included a DKIM signature. Therefore, I am unable to authenticate the email and determine if the message was altered during transit. The Auth Result is none.

 

[Stoiko Ivanov]

please share the logs from PMG of this testmail.

Also keep in mind that DKIM Signing only happens if you relay through the internal port of PMG

I hope this helps!

 

[Amgems]

please share the logs from PMG of this testmail.

Also keep in mind that DKIM Signing only happens if you relay through the internal port of PMG

I hope this helps!

I was confused. I thought "sign all outgoing mail" meant: sign all outgoing mail. Reading the documents more carefully, I see that it does state the fact that only the ones received on the internal port are signed.

I have more or less resigned myself to the fact that I just wasted 176 Euro. Disabled the PMG VM and instead installed `mailu` and that was up an working with full replacement DNS entries automatically working within 60 minutes or so.

I do not regret my PVE license fee though. That was and remains well worth it.