Advice Needed: Best Low-Power 6-Bay NAS for Proxmox Backup Server (PBS) at Home

UK SPEED

Member
Dec 23, 2023
92
3
13
Hi everyone,

I'm looking for advice on building or buying a dedicated backup storage system for my Proxmox servers.

I want to keep the backup system at home, running 24/7, with the lowest possible electricity consumption.

My requirements are:

  • Support for Proxmox Backup Server (PBS), preferably installed directly on the hardware.
  • At least 6 HDD bays, preferably without disks included.
  • Low power consumption, especially when idle.
  • Reliable hardware suitable for 24/7 operation.
  • Good compatibility with Proxmox and Linux.
  • Budget of around $800 (excluding HDDs).
  • Preferably a ready-built NAS, although I'm open to other solutions.
I'm considering devices from TerraMaster, UGREEN, or a small low-power server.

My questions are:

  1. Which NAS or low-power server would you recommend for running Proxmox Backup Server?
  2. Has anyone successfully installed PBS directly on a 6-bay NAS?
  3. Which hardware offers the best balance between power consumption, reliability, and performance?
  4. What is the actual idle power consumption of your setup, with and without HDDs?
  5. Would you recommend a dedicated PBS installation or using a NAS with backup storage shared over NFS?
I'm particularly interested in hearing from people who already run a similar setup at home.

Any recommendations, real-world experiences, or hardware suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks in advance!
 
If you will run Proxmox Backup Server (PBS), then you will have a zfs pool with ssd.
Only hdds will not work and you must calculate 8 watt power for every hdd cmr nas drive with 7200 rpm.
So i assume in total 80 watt.

What about pc hardware?
1) ASRock B550 PRO4 or ASRock B550m PRO4, ryzen 5 5600 (none x), ddr4 16 gb, pcie 4.0 and 1 gbit/s lan?
2) ASRock B550 PG Riptide same as above and 2.5 gbit/s lan?

If you only need pcie 3.0 with out ecc ddr4 ram, you can use a ryzen 5000 G cpu, ex. AMD Ryzen 3 5300G.
Any amd ryzen pro 5000 G cpu give you ddr4 ecc support with pcie 3.0. Maybe you will find some used.
If you can find amd ryzen pro 5 4650g or ryzen pro 7 4750g get one.
 
Thank you for your detailed recommendations.

My main priority is the lowest possible power consumption, as the system will run 24/7 at home.

Would an Intel N100 or N305 system be more power-efficient than the Ryzen options you suggested?

I'm planning to use 6 HDDs for Proxmox Backup Server, with an SSD for the operating system.

Also, do you think running PBS on an existing server in my data centre, with additional HDDs, would be a better and more economical solution than building a separate home NAS?

I'm particularly interested in real-world idle power consumption.
 
So think of your setup PBS need SSDs IOPs! So only hdds will not work, as you expected. you also need Compote power for calculate. Can you use ECC Ram on your low power Desktop PC.

A PBS is not a NAS, it serve you to backup proxmox ve lxc and vm in the first place.

Pleased search for opinions in the German part of this Proxmox Forum too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UdoB
How many lxc and vm do you have, have you ever use zfs as underlying file - and storage system.

Do you every read something about zfs special device on flash drives, i.a. ssd flash storage with dram cache with plp on tlc cells, sata III work fine for me.

I think you don't now yet what you want.
 
For a nas simple take a UGREEN NASync DXP6800 Pro/ Ultra 6-Bay, add extra ddr5 memory and a nas server os and you are fine.

But Promox BS must run on its own drives, not over a slow network.
 
Last edited:
I run PBS on my TrueNAS box as a LXC container. My trueNAS box is based on a upcycled Asrock Rack S4P2143/D2143D8UM motherboard that I pulled out of a Datto S4XP4000 Intel Xeon D-2143 machine that I picked up on ebay for $249. I did a few upgrades: I rehomed the motherboard into a 2U case for quieter fans, added a couple of Icy Dock 6 Bay hot swap enclosures, (MB326SP-B), and replaced the Mezzanine network card with a Mellanox CX4421A ConnectX-4 LX Dual Port SFP28 mezzanine card. I added an Optane P4801X as a SLOG and I am using six SM863 SATA SSD drives in three mirrored VDEVs. At the wall this set up is pulling 50 watts. It serves as my main storage for my homelab: NFS shares for Docker workloads, iSCSI LUNs for Proxmox, as well as my PBS machine. My Synology DS-1621+ with four hard drives and two NVME SSDs as a cache draws about 35 watts by comparison.

You can use spinning disks for PBS, so long as you keep the data store below say 5-10TB, otherwise it will be painfully slow. You would also want to use multiple mirrors of hard disks along with a special metadata VDEV on NVME storage, so the garbage collection and verify jobs don't take forever. But if you do that, you might need more than six drive bays.

All in my server cost me:
$249 for the motherboard, CPU and some RAM
$60 for the 2U case and power supply from Facebook Marketplace
$75 for the Mellanox ConnectX-4
$100 for the Optane
$190 for additional RAM to get to 128GB.
$90 for the Icydock (you only need one)

So all in, without drives, I was just under $800. This machine is very fast. Faster than almost any pre-made NAS, and serves double duty as my main storage server, and a PBS machine. I love it. I back it up to my Synology, which is mostly used/owned by my wife for family photos, documents, etc. And then I back that machine up to a couple of different places locally and on the cloud.
 
I'm planning to use 6 HDDs for Proxmox Backup Server, with an SSD for the operating system.
The only combination from my point of view is to have some HDD and at least two SSD/NVMe for a Special Device. A separate disk for the OS is... not necessary at all.

In a nutshell: during installation install on all HDDS, in Mirrored/Raid10. (Welcomed side effect: at the end every disk is bootable.)

When everything is up and running add a Special Device by utilizing two good SSDs. Calculate 0.3% of the pool size for this. (Or take larger ones and read about "special_small_blocks".)
 
  • Like
Reactions: news
I dissagree. Ofc you can run PBS on ”only hdd”?. Whys this focus on SSD Iops?

On topic. You can pickup alot of Dell T430 cheap on the internet refurbished. In sweden its 300-600 euro depending on shape and ram/cpu. Its a quite good CPU for the job. Platinum psu usualy and u get 8x3,5 hotswap bays with hba passthrough card. I have one with an E-2224 CPU, 32gb RAM and 2x3,5 hdd at about 52-56w idle.
 
PBS will run on HDD-only at home scale; the SSD emphasis is mostly for a ZFS special/metadata vdev so GC and verify don't crawl as the datastore grows. For a 6-bay low-power build within $800, I'd lean DIY or a used 6–8 bay tower rather than a ready NAS if you want PBS installed directly—boot/driver support on NAS appliances is hit-or-miss. Install PBS on mirrored HDDs to save a bay, and use two small SSDs on internal SATA for the special vdev. Keep the datastore local; NFS-backed PBS storage adds latency and another failure point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UdoB
I dissagree.
You may, of course :-)

This anecdote is some years old (when PBS was very new) and I am not sure how it applies today - as all my newer PBS (with HDDs) do have a Special Device:

My very first PBS used only rotating rust. First it worked great. After putting a few TB of actual data on it I noticed timeouts. The listing of the backups simply failed. Trying it immediately again would succeed - because now most part of the metadata was already read and stored in Ram.

The reason in my case was just a too-slow storage system. After realizing this I had added some fast metadata devices - and since then the system worked.

What I want to say: PBS needs IOPS. With a slow storage system you may get into trouble, but often only later (instead of from-the-start) when the PBS contains already a large amount of data. Then to list the content of a large storage needs to physically move the head of an HDD just too often...

Nevertheless: your mileage may vary :-)
 
Last edited: