PBS Backup a MacBook?

Worth clarifying that PBS isn’t a Time Machine destination itself—it exposes a backup datastore/API, not an SMB target macOS can select in Time Machine. The Homebrew cask above looks like a third-party client, so I’d check whether it does scheduled snapshots and, more importantly, a tested restore path. If it only uploads files, it’s not equivalent to Time Machine. Has anyone restored a full Mac from it?
 
For usage of mount and map you need to install FUSE-T.
FUSE is IMHO a disaster waiting to happen.
Heck, SMB timemachine backups don't really work well.
Only TimeMachine that works reliable it to an external APFS USB disk.

If you really want to have network time machine, you could simply create a SMB share on PBS.

So honestly, I don't really understand what users are asking here and why. PBS is a backup tool for PVE. That is it. It does not need to offer TimeMachine nor Windows Server backup. That is not what it is for.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tmanok
FUSE is IMHO a disaster waiting to happen.
Heck, SMB timemachine backups don't really work well.
Only TimeMachine that works reliable it to an external USB disk.

If you really want to have network time machine, you could simply create a SMB share on PBS.

So honestly, I don't really understand what users are asking here and why. PBS is a backup tool for PVE. That is it. It does not need to offer TimeMachine nor Windows Server backup. That is not what it is for.
Correct. Apple has barely touched Time Machine since it killed AFP in 2013, and since about 2018 I've personally noticed increased corruption errors on networked backups.

Re: SMB on PBS. Unless you've installed PBS locally on bare metal (what a waste of resources in most cases (especially in the RAM-pocalypse)) or your backend is S3 buckets, you probably already have a NAS or if you're in a big enough environment to have a SAN, you probably have VMs with SMB file shares. So I wouldn't even go so far as to modify your PBS by adding an SMB share, that's like asking PVE to become a file server, literally not its job- these are specialized enterprise grade applications and they're built with stability in mind, this kind of thinking is scope-creep.

Cheers,


Tmanok
 
  • Like
Reactions: IsThisThingOn
Worth clarifying that PBS isn’t a Time Machine destination itself—it exposes a backup datastore/API, not an SMB target macOS can select in Time Machine. The Homebrew cask above looks like a third-party client, so I’d check whether it does scheduled snapshots and, more importantly, a tested restore path. If it only uploads files, it’s not equivalent to Time Machine. Has anyone restored a full Mac from it?
Ah yes! Not a Time Machine clone or so.

If it only uploads files, it’s not equivalent to Time Machine
Yea, not sure the full TimeMachine like integration is possible.
But having my user home folder on PBS is already quite good. The system partition you can get from a clean install.

Has anyone restored a full Mac from it?
I did some tinkering around that and tested a full user restore in a VM. I dont have a spare mac at to test with that.
So far the file restore aspect works nicely and I keep looking into a better integration for the restore.


Heck, SMB timemachine backups don't really work well.
If you really want to have network time machine, you could simply create a SMB share on PBS.
Yea, as you say yourself, the whole SMB stuff is a bit finicky. So why not use a proper backend then?
 
Last edited:
Yea, as you say yourself, the whole SMB stuff is a bit finicky. So why not use a proper backend then?
What is a proper backend to you?
To only "proper" way to backup macOS with TimeMachine is an external APFS USB drive.

I mostly only use TM to have another backup of my Nextcloud, since the days of backing up machines are IMHO over.
There is nothing on PCs anymore.
Even if my macmini crashed tomorrow, and even though I have a TM backup, I would never ever restore from it.
I know people that have like 15y old macOS installes, that they upgraded and transfered from old to new macs. Your are just dragging along old bloat IMHO.

I even feel the same for most of my VMs. I mean, what is an immich VM? A MAC address or static IPv6, plus a compose file and some NFS share. Not really worth backing up the whole VM. I do, because I run PBS anyway for more complicated stuff and I am lazy. But for most people, you are better IMHO better off writing a log or doc during the installation.