experiences with HP proliant and HA

[debi@n]

Hi, i Work with HP proliant(3 servers pm cluster), proxmox and i tried work with HA time ago, but HA had bad results for me with proliants servers, could you share your experiences with HA and HP ?
and
how can i solve this?

Thanks!

 

[LnxBil]

Using it for 2 years now, 24x7 without any problems.

Without any further information, we cannot help you.

 

[debi@n]

Hi, what hardware are you using? we have G6 DL360 X2 , G5 DL160.
Thanks!!!

 

[Belokan]

Hello. What do you mean by "HA had bad results" ?

 

[adamb]

Just going out on a limb, but maybe your issue was the hardware watchdog not being blacklisted. We have gen8/gen9's and should have some gen10's here real soon with no issues. We have lots of them in the field.

 

[fireon]

Yes Hardwarewatchdog does not work on HP. Only using softdog.

 

[debi@n]

Hi, thanks for the replies, i did the next time ago.
-ASR disabled
-hpwdt module blacklisted.

and when i tried use HA, i had randoms reboots! :S but i will test on proxmox 5 and i will tell

 

[debi@n]

Hello. What do you mean by "HA had bad results" ?

randoms reboots that i experimented, without HA, all was good

 

[LnxBil]

Hi, what hardware are you using?

DL360G6

 

[debi@n]

DL360G6

are using softdog? for HA?
Thanks

 

[LnxBil]

In PVE 4, i did not change the default behaviour. I used hardware watchdog in PVE 3.