UdoB's latest activity
-
UdoB replied to the thread What should I do about this? Warning on boot.You may read the release notes before executing an upgrade ;-) --> https://pve.proxmox.com/wiki/Upgrade_from_8_to_9#cgroup_V1_Removal -
UdoB replied to the thread [SOLVED] web ui or ssh access stops working after a while.Are you sure the answer of "ping" came from this server? Or does it come from the machine using that IP address in that moment? (Hint: you can not know that without examining the MAC address.) The first suspicion is an IP address conflict. I...
-
UdoB reacted to bbgeek17's post in the thread [SOLVED] Quorum requirements question - minimum number with
Like.
Yes, if you loose 4 out of 8 nodes you have an issue. You need to have an odd number of nodes. If you have your cluster split in two rooms, you need the deciding vote (could be a q-device) located in a 3rd room/location. It should be equally... -
UdoB reacted to ewallig@triangleaviation.'s post in the thread [SOLVED] Quorum requirements question - minimum number with Like.
Solid advice - I'll look into this option as well, thanks. Yup, that scenario has not escaped my thought process - plan on doing the Q-Device for as long as I have an even number of nodes but might try and experiment with the "maintenance-mode"...
-
UdoB reacted to bbgeek17's post in the thread [SOLVED] Quorum requirements question - minimum number with Like.
@UdoB is correct for a one-time procedure. It may be a good time to think about what would happen in a non-orderly shutdown (loss of the room), and to implement good practices. Cheers Blockbridge : Ultra low latency all-NVME shared storage for...
-
UdoB replied to the thread [SOLVED] Quorum requirements question - minimum number.Integrating an independent Quorum Device is the correct solution for "normal use". You go for maintenance and I expect you to have an eye on the remaining cluster during that time. In this case you can circumvent the Quorum problem by telling...
-
UdoB reacted to Johannes S's post in the thread Bios zurückgesetzt, Proxmox Server fährt nicht mehr hoch - KI versagt komplett with Like.
Darum ist PBS empfehlenswert, dessen Deduplizierung spart einiges an Speicherplatz, die Performance mit Netzwerkfreigaben macht aber nicht gerade Freude, mit lokalen SSDs ( oder notfalls HDD im mirror mit einen ssd mirror als special device) ist...
-
Der Punkt ist halt, dass es mit Netzwerkfreigaben generell langsamer und fehleranfälliger ist. Im NFS-Thread hat der User mit den Umzug auf eine VM direkt auf der NAS eine deutliche Beschleunigung für die regelmäßigen Wartungsjobs (garbage...
-
UdoB reacted to Johannes S's post in the thread Bios zurückgesetzt, Proxmox Server fährt nicht mehr hoch - KI versagt komplett with Like.
Viel wichtiger finde ich bei solchen Setups noch das Backup. Aber auch für den ProxmoxBackupServer eignet sich günstige alte Hardware ganz gut ;) Und wenn man einen Mini-PC nimmt, hält sich der Stromverbrauch ja in Grenzen, grün hin oder her...
-
UdoB replied to the thread Problems about PBS verify workers.Yeah, that's great! :-) Maybe. Maybe not. How much Ram does the system have? For ARC? When you started that command for the first time the very first thing it does is to create the testfile by writing to it. After doing so the whole content...
-
UdoB reacted to Johannes S's post in the thread Bios zurückgesetzt, Proxmox Server fährt nicht mehr hoch - KI versagt komplett with Like.
Ernst gemeinte Frage (nicht böse gemeint!): Warum setzt man ein System in der Firma auf, was man nur mit KI eingerichtet bekommen hat? Schon zuhause wäre mir das zu heikel (kann man aber natürlich auch anders sehen, je nach dem wie wichtig einen...
-
UdoB replied to the thread Problems about PBS verify workers.During backup (=writing new data) or verify = reading chunks? Assuming verify for now, so: You have three vdevs --> the IOPS of three spindles. You need to read a lot (approx. 12 million) of 4 MiB chunks, several will be smaller. 66 MB/s per...
-
Are you running your Pihole in a unprivileged container? Then this is normal, since containers share the Proxmox host kernel and don't have this permission. Change you Pihole to stop trying to sync the hardware clock with network time. EDIT: I...
-
UdoB reacted to supersloth's post in the thread Problem with PCIe passthrough of HBA for TrueNAS Scale VM? with Like.
Yes, and I will link you to my desperate post on truenas forum https://forums.truenas.com/t/multiple-issues-half-recovered-now-but-have-question/50320 This is me, and this is the same issue, I just approached it from a different angle
-
Nope it's not. But: A cluster brings additional complexity and (thus) additional potential failures. For example: You should have at least three nodes like explained by Udo above. That can be mitigated with a qdevice (a raspberry would work or a...
-
UdoB reacted to Johannes S's post in the thread Aufbau eines HA Clusters mit ZFS-Storage oder externem Storage with Like.
Mittlerweile nicht mehr: Dafür halte ich auch den Weg mit der Storage-Replication für den Schmerzfreiesten mit dem geringsten Ausfallrisiko. Ja, man hat da im worstcase einen Datenverlust von einer Sekunde und es mag Anwendungen geben, wo das...
-
UdoB reacted to bbgeek17's post in the thread questions about creating users in proxmox using Linux PAM Standard Authentication with Like.
This is correct, the user and their permissions apply to all nodes in the cluster. System-Wide refers to "Linux PAM" which is not PVE specific. Its a generic Linux concept. The "system" in this particular wording is the server/node. Each...
-
Hello, Running PBS 4 on Debian 12 Bookworm is not officially supported, and while it might be technically possible to force the installation, you’d be stepping into risky territory. It may encounter dependency conflicts, especially with newer...
-
UdoB replied to the thread ZFS Single Disk Setup - Best Practice for longevity and efficiency.Yes, there is no need to use ZFS and ZFS really shines with multiple drives. But a) ZFS replication b) transparent compression c) technically cheap snapshots d) data integrity checks / bit-rot-detection(!) and some more features (e.g...
-
UdoB replied to the thread Aufbau eines HA Clusters mit ZFS-Storage oder externem Storage.Technisch ist das aber dennoch ein SPOF, oder nicht? Wir reden hier aber von einem Homelab. Und selbst wenn der NFS-Server auf der oben erwähnten Synology ultra-stabil wäre: das essentielle Netzwerk ist vermutlich ebenfalls nicht redundant und...