Recent content by NdK73

  1. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    Ah, ok. So if I have 3 rooms, 3 nodes per room and size=5 I can be sure that downing a single host won't take down more than one replica. Downing a room, on the other hand, will take down up to two replicas. Right? I'm actually thinking about adding osds to have a "capacity pool" on hdd and...
  2. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    Not sure I understand. If there's one replica per room, and each host can only be in one room, two replicas cannot be on the same host...
  3. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    Tks a lot! Couldn't see it. No idea WHY it's 2 instead of 3... Now I've run ceph osd pool set main_3 size 3 and it started recovery... It won't finish before virt3 comes back online, but I hope it will prevent a future down.
  4. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    Yes, the cluster was healthy. Maybe the pgs are not active because they've never been used? root@virt1:~# pveceph pool ls --noborder Name Size Min Size PG Num min. PG Num Optimal PG Num PG Autoscale Mode PG Autoscale Target Size PG Autoscale Target Ratio Crush Rule Name %-Used...
  5. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    The cluster was healthy. And virt3 node is still down :( The remaining nodes (virt1 and virt2) can see each other and are actually recognized to form a quorum: root@virt1:~# ceph -s cluster: id: a76df3b3-8b6d-42da-a901-47e80c660df4 health: HEALTH_WARN 1/3 mons down...
  6. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    That's what I understood, too. But practice says it does not work. So I'm trying to understand why and what can I do to make it work ASAP...
  7. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    Well, I'm OK for ceph to be degraded for some time: it should just continue writing to the other two copies! That's the whole reason to keep 3 copies: continue to write even if one goes down! Else I'd choose just 2 copies, so that if a node goes down the cluster heals on the remaining two. With...
  8. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    That seems quite unrelated: it just happens that the power outage took down both virt3 and PBS. Once I disabled PBS storage, virt1 answered again.
  9. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    That's what I thought. If only Proxmox thought the same... :) There's a monitor on each host, as default setup, and the quorum is met. Moreover, now the Proxmox interface hangs when trying to access Ceph dashboard. Paint me even more confused! Actually ceph does not say anything about being...
  10. N

    [SOLVED] 3-node cluster

    Hello all. I deployed a 3-node cluster w/ ceph, one node per server room, to be able to keep working when (not if) one of the rooms goes down. Too bad it seems that Proxmox stops IO even when ceph cluster would still be working: the result is that a downed room blocks all the VMs in the cluster...
  11. N

    Race between "Prune & GC" and new backups leads to corrupt dumps

    Tried looking at it but IIUC I'd need 3 new vdevs with the same raidz3 layout just for metadata... One SSD can probably be added, the second could even be hammered in, but 3 or more is not possible and 18 would be plain ridiculous.
  12. N

    Race between "Prune & GC" and new backups leads to corrupt dumps

    I sometimes click the 'v' next t othe pencil for the latest backup and it gets marked 'ok'. At next gc I'll see if the verified ones become corrupt or not. But it seems pbs does not handle well big backups (like the one containing a 32TB disk): nearly 3 days for a complete backup, way more for...
  13. N

    Race between "Prune & GC" and new backups leads to corrupt dumps

    Here it is. But packages got updated yesterday, after fixing the backups. root@pbs:~# proxmox-backup-manager version --verbose proxmox-backup 3.2.0 running kernel: 5.15.131-2-pve proxmox-backup-server 3.2.7-1 running version: 3.2.7...
  14. N

    Race between "Prune & GC" and new backups leads to corrupt dumps

    Hello. Seems the job for prune & GC does not account for data generated by concurrent backups. In my case GC takes 17 days (on 24 16TB SAS disks configured as a single pool containing 3 RAIDZ3 - it's simply economically unfeasible to have the same amount of storage on SSD just for backups!)...
  15. N

    Changing boot order from inside a VM

    Handle automated reinstallation of the OS, initiated by the guest itself. But not every boot have to be a reinstall. Changing the boot order is usually the easiest thing to do.