gurubert's latest activity
-
gurubert reacted to bbgeek17's post in the thread Planning network infrastructure for virtualization and future expansion with
Like.
Hi @rosiecharles, 25GbE is really the starting point for modern greenfield business deployments. If you are planning for future growth, starting with 100GbE infrastructure and using breakout cables to provide 25GbE connectivity may be a good... -
Hello, I wonder, what's the rationale behind a tool like this. What problem is it trying to solve?
-
We have a 24 node cluster, some on 10G, soon all will be on 2x100G. No problems, even having 14 nodes on a very busy 2x10G segment, with Ceph and no dedicated fabric. Things are way more robust than people like to make it sound. There are some...
-
gurubert reacted to Johannes S's post in the thread Clarification about Ceph suitability for a 2-node storage architecture with a witness/quorum node with Like.
Don't. Ceph needs at least three nodes unless you change the defaults ( and doing this is a bad idea, see: https://forum.proxmox.com/threads/ceph-pool-size-is-2-1-really-a-bad-idea.68939/ ) The recommended requirements in the documentation are...
-
gurubert reacted to MarkusKo's post in the thread Clarification about Ceph suitability for a 2-node storage architecture with a witness/quorum node with Like.
No, Ceph needs at least 3 nodes, for production 5 nodes or more (odd number) are recommended: PVE docs
-
gurubert reacted to UdoB's post in the thread Clarification about Ceph suitability for a 2-node storage architecture with a witness/quorum node with Like.
Two years ago I tried to use Ceph in my homelab. My experience: https://forum.proxmox.com/threads/fabu-can-i-use-ceph-in-a-_very_-small-cluster.159671/ I am not a Ceph user now. But I would not start with fewer than five active nodes. Just my...
-
Have you already purchased the motherboards? If not price out single cpu systems with plenty of memory. The savings over dual cpu ( assuming you were pricing that out) may leave cash to afford nvme’s or data a center grade ssd
-
It depends on your performance expectations, but ceph is quite capable to deal with this kind of mixed hardware- as long as you make sure that you have EQUIVALENT CAPACITY PER OSD TYPE on each osd server. In your case, assuming you want all 6...
-
Hi AllYourSmurf if you are able to do so, you should distribute your nvmes more equally across, the nvme nodes or even better across all nodes. With the current distribution only 3TB of your NVME-Storages will be usable (with the default 3-2...
-
gurubert reacted to IsThisThingOn's post in the thread [Community project] Proximo — an open-source, least-privilege MCP/API layer for managing PVE with an AI agent (feedback wanted) with Like.
You brought it up, not me. Just a friendly advice, based on my personal experience. Nothing more, nothing less. Feel free to ignore it. But back to topic. Let us not put the cart before the horse. Why should I even want to manage PVE with an AI...
-
gurubert reacted to meyergru's post in the thread [Community project] Proximo — an open-source, least-privilege MCP/API layer for managing PVE with an AI agent (feedback wanted) with Like.
@broadway: Let’s take a step back from the technical scaffolding you are proposing. Hash-chains, dry-runs, and scoped RBAC tokens are standard practices for traditional API automation. They do not, however, mitigate the core issue we are...
-
gurubert reacted to meyergru's post in the thread [Community project] Proximo — an open-source, least-privilege MCP/API layer for managing PVE with an AI agent (feedback wanted) with Like.
If the token only needs read-only privileges, the agent cannot actually do anything harmful, that is correct. On the other hand - it cannot do anything at all.
-
gurubert reacted to IsThisThingOn's post in the thread [Community project] Proximo — an open-source, least-privilege MCP/API layer for managing PVE with an AI agent (feedback wanted) with Like.
Not trying to be a dick, but I would never run software maintained by a single person with mental health issues. But back to topic. Let us not put the cart before the horse. Why should I even want to manage PVE with an AI agent? Proxmox is...
-
gurubert reacted to Johannes S's post in the thread [Community project] Proximo — an open-source, least-privilege MCP/API layer for managing PVE with an AI agent (feedback wanted) with Like.
The thing is: I don't trust ai to follow any guard rails or safety rules. So: Your answer doesn't change anything. Your answer to @meyergru concerns is basically "trust me bro" which also doesn't help your case. W
-
gurubert reacted to meyergru's post in the thread [Community project] Proximo — an open-source, least-privilege MCP/API layer for managing PVE with an AI agent (feedback wanted) with Like.
Thanks for sharing your project here. I appreciate that you openly state this is a human+AI hybrid project. However, looking closely at the concept, the GitHub profile, and the architectural choice, I see three potential scenarios here—all of...
-
gurubert reacted to Johannes S's post in the thread [Community project] Proximo — an open-source, least-privilege MCP/API layer for managing PVE with an AI agent (feedback wanted) with Like.
I'm not interested in using an AI agent at all on my hosts because my data is too important for me: https://www.euronews.com/next/2026/04/28/an-ai-agent-deleted-a-companys-entire-database-in-9-seconds-then-wrote-an-apology In other words: I...
-
https://proxmox.com/en/partners/find-partner/explore
-
I would setup a VPN server like Wireguard or OpenVPN. Once you have that setup you VPN in and then can access everything on your network. I have mine setup in a way where I need to authenticate myself first on a hidden web page which unblocks...
-
From PVE's perspective, q3ded is an application for a Linux host as any other. So you just set up an LXC container or QEMU VM with a GNU/Linux distribution of your choice in it on PVE, make sure it's properly available on the local network, and...
-
the documentation might benefit from a note that using cephfs will (as of now) prevent use of some current ceph features. agreed. the kernel cephfs does not advertise the reef features. because the pg-upmap-primary needs the cooperation of...