fencing via fence_node using ipmi not working

[ladmini]

Hi there,

fence_node using fence_ipmilan is not working, alway returns status failed.
This is the latest pve-version, there was something mentioned in the changelog, but nothing to specific
pveversion
pve-manager/3.3-1/a06c9f73 (running kernel: 2.6.32-32-pve)

fence_tool ls
fence domain
member count 2
victim count 0
victim now 0
master nodeid 1
wait state none
members 1 2

ipmitool is working
ipmitool -I lanplus -H '172.24.10.91' -U 'papagena' -P ' ' -v chassis power status Chassis
Power is on

fence_ipmilan is working as expected, using a script for the password
fence_ipmilan -a 172.24.10.92 -l papagena -S /usr/local/bin/FOSubnetPW.php --action=status
Status: ON
Although the password script is written in php, it is in fact a CLI, it could have been named "FOSubnetPW.sh" as well

fence_node -S paymox-02 -vv
status paymox-02 dev 0.0 agent fence_ipmilan result: status error
agent args: nodename=paymox-02 action=status agent=fence_ipmilan lanplus=1 ipaddr=172.24.10.92 login=papagena passwd_script=/usr/local/bin/FOSubnetPW.php power_wait=10
status paymox-02 failed -1
or if we try to reboot the node:
fence_node paymox-02 -vv
fence paymox-02 dev 0.0 agent fence_ipmilan result: error from agent agent args: nodename=paymox-02 agent=fence_ipmilan lanplus=1 ipaddr=172.24.10.92
login=papagena passwd_script=/usr/local/bin/FOSubnetPW.php power_wait=10 fence paymox-02 failed

Actually, I tried without my fancy password scirpt, did not work either. Any ideas, howto get fencing up and running?

 

[adamb]

Seems pretty much identical to the issues I am facing. I just created a new thread.

http://forum.proxmox.com/threads/19928-Fence-Issues

Did you ever find a resolution?

 

[ladmini]

No, sadly not. I use another fencing method now, custom made with "stonith".

 

[adamb]

No, sadly not. I use another fencing method now, custom made with "stonith".

Just a heads up that my issue ended up being lanplus, once I disabled, fencing started working as expected.